Dell Studio 15 VS BenQ S42 .. dan Dell XPS 16 VS BenQ S57

nak mintak pendapat korang la..pilih yg mana..? nyatakn sebab jugak..

specs..

BenQ Joybook S42
Centrino Platform: Montevina
CPU: Intel Core 2 Duo P8400/P8600/P8700
Chipset: Intel GM45 + ICH9-M
Graphic: Nvidia GeForce 9600M GT 256MB GDDR3, Intel Graphic Media Accelerator X4500MHD
Wireless: Intel WiFi Link 5300
Monitor: 14.1" UltraVivid @ 1280x800, 8ms response time
Weight: 2.4kg with battery
8X DVD+/-RW Drive with DVD+R double layer write capability

Price. RM 3k++

Dell Studio 15
Intel Core 2 Duo Processor P8700 (2.53GHz/ 1066 FSB/ 3MB Cache)
4GB (2X2GB) DDR2 SDRAM Memory
500GB SATA Hard Drive
512MB ATI Mobility Radeon HD 4570
Slot Load 8X DVD+/-RW Drive with DVD+R double layer write capability
15.6 " 720p WLED (1366x768) Display with TrueLife(TM) w/Camera

price. 3.3k++


Dell Studio XPS 16
Intel Core 2 Duo Processor P8700 (2.53GHz/ 1066 FSB/ 3MB Cache)
Genuine Windows Vista(R) Home Premium SP1 64 bit Edition (English)
4GB (2 X 2GB) Dual Channel 1066MHz DDR3 SDRAM
320GB 7200RPM SATA Hard Drive
Obsidian Black 15.6 " 1080p WUXGA (1920x1080) WLED Full HD Display w/ 2MP cam
1GB ATI Mobility Radeon HD 4670
Slot Load 8X DVD + /-RW Drive with double layer write capability

Price. 4.1k++

BenQ S57
BenQ Joybook S57
Centrino Platform: Montevina
CPU: Intel Core 2 Duo P8700
Chipset: Intel PM45 + ICH9-M
Graphic: AMD-ATi Mobility Radeon HD 4650 512MB DDR3
Wireless: Intel WiFi Link 5100
Monitor: 15.6" UltraVivid @ 1366x768, 8ms response time
Weight: 2.8kg with battery
8X DVD+/-RW Drive with DVD+R double layer write capability
Blu-Ray COMBO

price. RM 3799++


pendapat aku.. klo Studio 15 VS BenQ S42..
memang kedua2nya lebih kurang je spec..
Studio 15 lawa sket design..
tapi entah kenapa
aku lebih suke BenQ S42..

klo Studio XPS 16 VS BenQ S57
sememangnya.. Studio XPS 16 menang dari segi GPU ..
tetapi BenQ S57 ada Blu-RAY combo..

bagi ak baik amik dell studio 15 tu..sbb GC de power..
harga pon murah..ak rase kalu downgrade proc bole dapat 2.7k je laptop tu..

aku tak nak downgrade proc.. aku nak korang compare ikut proc/spec tuh..

aku pn vote for studio 15...

studio 15 le...

boleh terangkan.. kenapa memilih Dell Studio 15..[as saya memang xkisah sgt pasal warranty yang dell tawarkan..]

pastu antara Dell XPS16 ngan BenQ S57.. cmne plak..?

256MB DDR3 9600M GT performs much much better than 512MB DDR3 Radeon 4570
BenQ S42 wins over Dell Studio 15

For the best performance/price ratio, get BenQ S57..
512MB DDR3 Radeon 4650 performs fairly the same as 1GB DDR3 Radeon 4670
hence S57~SXPS16

Not to mention S57 has better lcd, 1366x768 compared to 1920x1080 in SXPS16
Bigger reso doesnt meant better performance, but bigger reso always means greater load to your GC

S57 without Blu-Ray you can get about RM3.4k ald
It depends on your usage preferences, and also your pocket la..

sheikomatic wrote:256MB DDR3 9600M GT performs much much better than 512MB DDR3 Radeon 4570
BenQ S42 wins over Dell Studio 15

For the best performance/price ratio, get BenQ S57..
512MB DDR3 Radeon 4650 performs fairly the same as 1GB DDR3 Radeon 4670
hence S57~SXPS16

Not to mention S57 has better lcd, 1366x768 compared to 1920x1080 in SXPS16
Bigger reso doesnt meant better performance, but bigger reso always means greater load to your GC

S57 without Blu-Ray you can get about RM3.4k ald
It depends on your usage preferences, and also your pocket la..

thx for the comment,.. ini yang membuatkan aku lebih percaya nak beli BenQ S42..hehe//[dah agak dah]

anyway.. for BenQ S57 VS XPS16 ..
i'm just not agreed if u say 512MB DDR3 Radeon 4650 performs fairly the same as 1GB DDR3 Radeon 4670
because..1GB DDR3 Radeon 4670 performs better.. anyway...512MB DDR3 Radeon 4650 is not bad too..

BenQ S57 has blu-Ray[this is the feature that i want].. Studio XPS also come with blu-ray[after customized.]..and the price become 4.8k..

so the conclusion .. i will buy BenQ S42 and BenQ S57...

Radeon 4670 is a higher-clocked Radeon 4650.. 675,800 compared to 600,800 in Radeon 4650..
Even 4670 has 1GB memory, both have same memory bandwidth.
So both have almost the same performance, but at same reso la.
Seriously, in fact, 4650 might outperform 4670.
If one at 1366x768 and the other at 1920x1080, cannot compare la, different story oredi..

If usage is strictly for gaming, better get 1366x768
Less burden for laptop GC, 1920x1080 is playable only with desktop GC

See here and here to read more

sheikomatic wrote:Radeon 4670 is a higher-clocked Radeon 4650.. 675,800 compared to 600,800 in Radeon 4650..
Even 4670 has 1GB memory, both have same memory bandwidth.
So both have almost the same performance, but at same reso la.
Seriously, in fact, 4650 might outperform 4670.
If one at 1366x768 and the other at 1920x1080, cannot compare la, different story oredi..

If usage is strictly for gaming, better get 1366x768
Less burden for laptop GC, 1920x1080 is playable only with desktop GC

See here and here to read more

yeah i agree for you if not comparing. with same screen size

any other comments about these laptops.?

topic closed..